Custom Cakes

Topps Bakery offers a wide variety of their every day cakes in all sizes for parties large and small. Or go full custom and order your cake from the ground up. Choose from our selection of cake flavors paired with your favorite filling. Then select your exterior frosting and decorations & colors.

Having a design epiphany? Bring us your sketch or photograph of your desired design and our magical bakers will recreate your dream in fondant and frosting!

Order your custom cakes today! Tel: (914) 337-4258

Artistry takes time…

Please allow Topps Bakery at Bronxville a minimum of 24 hours to create and deliver your custom order cakes.
We promise you will be rewarded with a delicious item that is sure to please your crowd.
Cake Sizes

Round Cakes: 6″, 8″ , 10″  |  Sheet Cakes: 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, Full Sheet

How many people does each cake serve?

Round Cakes: 6″ (4-6), 7″ (6-8), 8″ (8-10), 9″ (10-14), 10″ (15-20)  |  Sheet Cakes: 1/4 (15-20) , 1/2 (25-35), 3/4 (35-55), Full Sheet (55-70)
Custom Cakes

[You choose each component]

Cake Flavors:

Vanilla • Chocolate


Fudge • Lemon • Vanilla Buttercream • Chocolate Buttercream

Decoration Colors:

Pink • Blue • Yellow • Multi-color

Decoration Themes:

Baby/Child/Adult Birthday • Sweet Sixteen • Christenings • Bar or Bat Mitzvah • Corporate Events  • YOU DESIGN IT!


Vanilla Buttercream • Chocolate Buttercream • Whipped Cream • Fudge


Vanilla or Chocolate
Stock Cakes

[Choose from the following combinations]

Carrot Cake
(finished in cream cheese frosting)
Brownie Cake
(Chocolate cake with fudge)
Strawberry Shortcake
(Whipped cream and luscious fresh strawberries)
Chocolate Mousse
(creamy and dreamy)
Lemon Layer
(Layers of Lemon Cake & Lemon Filling)
Raspberry Chocolate Layer
(Chocolate Cake & raspberry filling)
Cannoli Cake
(with real Cannoli filling)
Lemon Coconut
Raspberry Vanilla Layer
(Vanilla Cake & Raspberry Filling)
German Chocolate
(with its traditional coconut frosting)
Black Forest Cake
(Devils food cake, whipped cream and cherry filling)
Red Velvet
(with Traditional Cream Cheese Frosting)
Lemon Mousse
Vanilla Fudge Layer
(vanilla cake • Fudge filling)
Vanilla Buttercream
Mocha Apricot
Chocolate Fudge Layer
(Chocolate Cake • Fudge filling)
Mocha Fudge
Shadow Layer
(Chocolate Layer Cake with Vanilla Buttercream)
All Fudge
(Fudge filling • Fudge icing)
(Traditional Napoleon Cream filling)

Topps Bakery at Bronxville is located in Westchester County, Bronxville NY. This 80-year-old establishment caters to the treasured memories of your childhood trips to your local bakery. We offer over 200 carefully crafted items including: specialty cakes, fancy butter cookies, authentic French macarons, pastries, cupcakes, muffins, donuts, traditional holiday cakes and pies, and a plethora of artisanal breads.

Beyond the grab and go bakery items – Topps Bakery at Bronxville also welcomes custom and wholesale orders.
Not sure what to give? A Topps Bakery gift certificate is a sweet gift for any occasion.